- Sets
- 28
- First
- #736
- Latest
- #792
- Span
- 56 episodes
A long-time regular known as 'The Anomaly' for his prolific joke writing. He closed the show with a new minute of dark, one-liner material.
APPEARANCES
Newest first
Episode #792
RegularGuests: Jimmy Carr, Luis J Gomez, Steve Rannazzisi.
Episode #791
RegularHe joked about Tinder dates and plus-sized dating apps, a long-time regular known for his dark, tight, one-liner style, tony referred to him as the 'real deal' and an elite closer for the show.
Guests: Jim Norton, Anthony Cumia.
Episode #790
RegularClosed the show with a new minute of material. He joked about Vietnam jackets and homeless women, while during his interview, he mentioned a dental crown fell out backstage just before his set.
Guests: Yung Gravy, Erik Griffin.
Episode #789
RegularA long-time regular known for his rapid-fire 'folks' jokes, his set featured seasonal Halloween-themed material.
Guests: Tim Butterly, Kirk Fox.
Episode #788
RegularA long-time regular and Tony's self-proclaimed favorite comedian. He performed a series of short, edgy one-liners to close out the comedy portion of the show.
Guests: Wheeler Walker Jr, Sam Tripoli.
Episode #787
RegularHe performed a brand new minute that included a joke about the Netflix logo. Performed despite losing his voice while headlining his first weekend. Tony described him as one of the most powerful regulars in the show's history.
Guests: Harland Williams, Jeremiah Watkins.
Episode #786
RegularNew minute on sliding into DMs and AI chatbot girlfriends, final comedian of the night. Tony said it was the loudest and longest pop from the crowd he has ever heard, and called him 'truly one of the best in the world right now.'
Guests: Donnell Rawlings, Sam Tallent.
Episode #785
RegularTony said no one had cracked the homeless-dog-joke premise before despite 10 to 20 attempts. Closed the show, introduced as 'the anomaly, the real deal', on the road with the show in Dallas, Houston, Las Vegas and the Moody Center on New Year's Eve.
Guests: Duncan Trussell, Kurt Metzger.
Episode #784
RegularClosed the show as the headlining regular, introduced as a phenom with pure momentum, new set on taking Krav Maga and on Black Panther. Tony noted he is now getting laughs on his setups.
Guests: Yakov Smirnoff, Ari Matti.
Episode #783
RegularClosing regular, introduced by Tony as his favorite comedian in the world to watch right now and one of the greatest regulars in the show's history, short, brutal new minute of one-liners that landed hard. In the interview he said he was thrilled to see his podcast partner Grant Adcock get pulled, and described a road trip across the country with Martin Phillips and Hans Kim in which Martin did the driving. Tony closed by telling the audience to protect him and his brain.
Guests: Gary Owen, Brian Simpson.
Episode #782
RegularTight set of short, hard-punchline jokes about dumb women and about being called 'daddy' in bed, ending on an altar boy tag. Closed the show as the regular Tony calls an anomaly and a freak of nature, fresh off two sets at Madison Square Garden. Tony raved at length about the writing and execution, Jerron Horton said he had never seen him live and compared him to a Rick and Morty version of Scarface, and Ron White (who marked 40 years in standup on September 17) said he walked out on the balcony to watch him, found him that good, and has since brought him up to do spots in the big room.
Guests: Ron White, Jerron Horton.
Episode #781
RegularRapid-fire joke-dense set on internet rabbit holes, the Epstein emails, religious texts and Amazon listings, which drew a standing-ovation-level reaction; Tony called him one of the best comedians working today and said nothing can stop his trajectory. Interview covered trying to get sleep before Madison Square Garden, which will be his first ever trip to New York, being about a year and a half into living in Austin, and admitting he mostly replies to commenters on Instagram and missed Tony's congratulations message on being made a regular, while closing set of the episode, introduced as the show's climax and 'a freak of nature' kept chained up all week.
Guests: Jeff Arcuri.
Episode #779
RegularShort, punchy set with a swastika-on-my-Tesla bit, a Germany/hide-and-seek tag, a role-play joke about a jellyfish sting, and a women's self-defense tag; the crowd gave him a standing ovation. Told a story about Southwest Airlines rerouting him on the way to Lubbock and Midland, Texas gigs, leaving him in a middle seat next to a baby, while closing regular, introduced by Tony as one of his favorite things in the history of the show and later as, without hesitation, the fastest rising comedian in the world. In the interview he and Adam Ray compared notes on following each other, including the night Pat's golden ticket was awarded, and he noted the pops get bigger every week.
Guests: Adam Ray.
Episode #778
RegularJimmy Carr gave him the biggest compliment of the night, praising four great jokes back to back, perfect delivery and persona, and the visible work behind the set. Closed the show as the super regular, introduced by Tony as possibly the perfect specimen of a comic who writes a new minute every week and the fastest rising comedian in the world, dense one-liner set on squirting, fake tears, rough sex, horse riding as the Texas abortion, and rape-versus-incest exceptions, tony hyped his upcoming Madison Square Garden debut, Las Vegas arena dates and an upcoming hour, plus a recent San Diego weekend where audiences stood up mid-set.
Guests: Jimmy Carr.
Episode #777
RegularClosed the episode with a brand new minute, introduced as one of the best joke writers and performers in the show's history and as having gone viral that week with a Hitler joke, minute covered gender reveal parties, threesomes and a Waymo/John Cena tag. Both panelists said they love him and noted they had been working the door since the club opened while regulars like him built the scene. In the interview he said that by the end what he wanted from the golden ticket was mainly not to have to wait with the sign-up crowd at Shakespeare's anymore, and described fights and people using the line for shelter, including one night that was reportedly Fuzzy and Drew Nickens wrestling over a girl, plugged Pat O'Neal Comedy on Instagram and YouTube, plus upcoming Madison Square Garden and Las Vegas dates.
Guests: Myles Johnson, Fuzzy Khilji.
Episode #776
RegularIn the interview he recalled his first-ever joke, in Providence, Rhode Island, about 'little person' being more offensive than a slur, and that the crowd rejected it, the closer, billed by Tony as the executioner of Kill Tony, exactly one minute of his trademark deadpan one-liners with the big physical faces: walking in on his parents, a Michael Jackson impersonator hired for a family party, and his sister's first period, a heckler threw him off at the top. Tony confirmed he is booked for Madison Square Garden in August and two nights in Vegas; Pat admitted he is nervous about the big rooms.
Guests: Brian Moses, Dave Landau.
Episode #775
RegularClosed the show as the marquee regular, with a tight joke-after-joke minute that Tony and Joe Rogan explicitly held up as the counterexample to the rest of the night's rambling sets. Tony noted he and Dedric are the only two who have to write a fresh minute every week. Plugged upcoming Kill Tony dates with him on the bill: Madison Square Garden on August 7 and 8, the MGM Dolby Live theater in Las Vegas in November, and New Year's Eve in Austin, plus his own San Diego run with Redban.
Guests: Joe Rogan, That Mexican Ot.
Episode #774
RegularClosed the show as the regular after Tony explained William Montgomery was sick, Ari Matti had added tour dates and Timmy No Brakes was saving material. Brand new minute of three very short, dark jokes about Hitler, TikTok and Queers for Palestine; Tony called the opener the greatest Hitler joke he has heard in 20 years. Interview covered that his first regular episode was airing that same day, and a story about telling his landlord he was about to be famous after quitting his job. Mike Finoia said he was like a David Lynch movie doing stand-up, tony nicknamed him 'The Real Deal'.
Guests: Joe Derosa, Mike Finoia.
Episode #773
RegularIn the interview he talked about launching a podcast with fellow Mothership doorman Grant Adcock and a third person, roughly six episodes recorded and four released, and pushback from listeners wanting a video version he does not want to do. Closed the show as the current undefeated top regular, with a brand new minute of short punchy one-liners. Has Hollywood shows lined up, is going to San Diego with Redban and Toronto with Tony, the night's audience drawing by Chris Rogers depicted him as the Joker.
Guests: Francisco Ramos, Derrick Stroup.
Episode #771
RegularIn the interview he confirmed he is sober -- quit drinking and cocaine -- and joked he celebrated his first week as a regular with Shirley Temples. Opened the show as the newest elite regular, made a regular just the week before and described by Tony as the first person ever upgraded from golden ticket winner to regular, first appearance where he knew in advance he'd be on, tight punchline minute (girls named America, homelessness, Redskins renaming, an NAACP acronym bit).
Guests: Brad Williams, Timmy No Brakes.
Episode #770
RegularVery dark, tightly written set - abortion, a red-confetti gender reveal, a vasectomy-as-microdosing line, and a bathroom-bill joke ending in 'not guilty.' Introduced as the full-time newest regular and closed the show. Tony said he only hits home runs. Sheryl, seeing him for the first time, compared him to Emo Philips on acid and told him not to change; Tom Segura, also seeing him for the first time, called it a fun, solid way to wrap the night. Redban announced he's bringing Pat to San Diego with Rachel Wolfson.
Guests: Tom Segura, Sheryl Underwood.
Episode #769
RegularClosed the episode as the newest regular, introduced by Tony as becoming his and Redban's favorite comedian, with a brand new minute of short punchy jokes about sloppy head, loving fat girls and a 'light-skinned Latina'.
Guests: Chris O'connor, Mat Edgar.
Episode #768
RegularBrand new minute of crude relationship material about his ex-girlfriend, his new girlfriend and a herpes bit, follow-up interview covered his strictly missionary preferences and his lack of interest in toys. Closed the show as the newest regular on Kill Tony, introduced by Tony as being on a terror. Both panel guests praised him: James McCann said he had seen him once before and was proud of the glow up, and Shane Gillis recognized him from the Netflix special.
Guests: Shane Gillis, James Mccann.
Episode #767
RegularJokes about autoerotic asphyxiation as 'the cinnamon challenge,' porn giving him unrealistic expectations of lesbians, dating a Jewish girl who turned out to be a lesbian ('the old double Ike'), and the ancient Jews at the Last Supper. Tony called it clearly the set of the night; the panel roasted his hair and vampire/Dr. Frankenstein look, while closing regular set, introduced as one of the most promising regulars with only a couple of appearances under his belt, luis J Gomez invited him to Skankfest and Tony offered him the Secret Show.
Guests: Ari Shaffir, Luis J. Gomez, Peyton Ruddy.
Episode #766
Golden TicketAge 30, writes roughly fifteen new jokes a week, one of the newest golden ticket winners, recently passed at the Mothership. Tony and Sam Tallent raved about the set and Tony promoted him on the spot to full-time regular, which Tony called a first in the show's history.
Guests: Sam Tallent.
Episode #765
Golden TicketInterview focused on his dating life and his almost completely empty Austin apartment (bare walls, one giant table, a single vanilla candle), while returning golden ticket winner opening the show with a brand new minute; Tony noted he appeared on the first Netflix episode taped at the Mothership.
Guests: Dustin Poirier, Ari Matti.
Episode #758
Golden TicketTony awarded him a golden ticket and said it was long overdue.
Guests: Donnell Rawlings, Trevor Wallace.
Episode #736
Bucket PullHe joked about his recent breakup and his love for steak and candy. Originally from Massachusetts, he now lives in Austin and works for a mortgage company. He previously appeared on the Netflix episode of the show and describes himself as an open micer who is bad at networking.
Guests: James Mccann, Dave Landau.
Career Arc
Pat O'Neill is a Kill Tony regular. He first came out of the bucket on #736 in September 2025, took a regular spot by #767 in May 2026. The archive has 28 of his sets, through #792.
First pulled from the bucket in episode number 736. Won a golden ticket in episode number 758. Became a regular in episode number 767.
Also on these lineups
Nicole Tran Mohamad Uall Jesse Lane Carmen Sarasillo Dedrick Flynn Cameron Riddle JP Madison Charles Lester Gregory Simpleton Dr. Tim T Miles Johnson Reggie Kush Brent Reed Jerry Debo Smith Matthew Delgado Riley Gilmore Galina Rivina Michael Moses Grant Adcock Matt Markman Steven C. Duncan Jake Coulter AJ Olyri Mason Bird