Drew Nickens

Existing golden ticket winner brought on first to debut a brand new minute; Tony noted he holds the record for most appearances on a single episode and hadn't been on in a while. Performed a new preacher character built around being Mormon until age 13, later rejoining the church after brain damage in exchange for a sexual favor from a solar-panel saleswoman. In the interview he explained his customized $7 Taco Bell box order in detail, which became a running bit for the rest of the night; Fuzzy also revealed a girl ghosted him and started dating Drew.

Introduced as the return of a past golden ticket winner who had not been on the show in a long time and who holds the record for most appearances in a single episode. Reported recently doing his first sold-out headlining set, 45 minutes for about 120 people, and has been touring with other golden ticket winners.

Returning after a six-month hiatus due to a competition loss in Nashville. He mentioned doing 90 minutes of standup a week during his time off and opening for Adam Ray. He joked about his high energy and his appearance on Netflix.

A Golden Ticket winner known for his high-energy delivery. He joked about his head injury and his grandmother. He lost the crowd noise competition and was told to take six months off from the show.