
Lineup
- 1Drew Nickens6:59Golden Ticket
He performed a high-energy set about Special Olympics and dating, followed by a confrontational interview where he joked about Tony's mother. From Washington State, he is a former elementary school teacher's son who suffered a traumatic brain injury.
- 2Ike Gazaryan12:28Bucket Pull
His interview focused on reading hilarious one-star Yelp reviews for his restaurant and his defensive responses to them, born in the Soviet Union and moved to San Francisco in 1998, he owns a Russian restaurant in San Diego called Pushkin.
- 3Matt Banwart26:55Bucket Pull
He joked about his tremors and discussed his hobby of collecting rookie cards for football players who never played in the NFL. A comedian for nine years originally from Iowa, he has a medical condition involving hand tremors.
- 4Jeffrey Lee36:04Bucket Pull
A 'high-functioning' homeless man living in a van who works as a day-shift door guy on Sixth Street. His set and interview were noted for a lack of punchlines, leading to a very awkward interaction with the panel.
- 5Ali Musa43:46Bucket Pull
He works for Uber Eats and discussed his secret childhood Christmas celebrations in a Muslim household. A Libyan-American comedian who has been doing stand-up for 13 years and lives in Austin.
- 6Anthony Walton49:51Bucket Pull
Moved to Austin from Dallas and has been doing comedy for seven years after being inspired by Tony in 2019. He performed a metal vocal demonstration during his interview.
- 7Davey Jackson55:31Bucket Pull
A returning comedian who discussed his 'breeding kink' and meeting Kyle Rittenhouse at a party, he also admitted to providing Xanax to guest Mark Normand in the past.
- 8Todd Tindle1:09:47Bucket Pull
Age 47, former oil field worker and reptile breeder from New Mexico who recently moved to Austin. He has five children by four different women and works security at the bar across the street.
- 9Tommie Tickles1:25:30Bucket Pull
He discussed his farm life, his wife's work bottle-feeding goats, and his specific internet search habits, age 50, farmer and rancher from Fredericksburg, Texas, making his stand-up debut.
- 10abomb?1:39:20Bucket Pull
He discussed a recent breakup and his business, The Pariah Pack, which trains and boards dogs, a dog trainer and illustrator from San Antonio known online as Abomination AJ.
- 11Jenni Rodriguez1:51:01Bucket Pull
A tire installer and supervisor at Costco who is recently engaged. This was her second time on the show; her first appearance involved her and her then-boyfriend both being pulled from the bucket.
- 12Ari Matti1:57:03Regular
Tony praised his work ethic and constant joke writing during the interview. The Estonian regular closed the show with a high-energy set about cancel culture and language.