Keegan Carmichael

Third appearance; the show's resident Mitch Hedberg lookalike/soundalike, which Tony dug into at length. One-liners about a stolen wallet with 8K of credit card debt, free cheese vs. paid queso on a burrito, a vegan sister eating alone on Thanksgiving, and 'in case of fire use stairs.' Claims 1,500 jokes and an hour of material, and teased an 'epiphany' he refused to explain beyond 'the ghost pivot.' Tony ended by offering him a Secret Show spot.

1. 28:14

   Episode #767

   May 11, 2026

   Bucket Pull

   Guests: Ari Shaffir, Luis J. Gomez, Peyton Ruddy.

   Watch set at 28:14View episode #767
2. 1:13:53

   Episode #749

   Dec 22, 2025

   Bucket Pull

   Delivers food by bicycle in Austin, once delivered to Longhorns coach Sarkisian, and got a big joke book, second time on the show. Tony walked back the previous Mitch Hedberg comparison, saying people had vouched that the one-liner style is genuinely his.

   Guests: Sly Stallone (Kyle Dunnigan), Tony Yayo.

   Watch set at 1:13:53View episode #749
3. 1:21:19

   Episode #730

   Aug 4, 2025

   Bucket Pull

   Originally from Illinois and has been doing comedy for a little over two years, he delivers for DoorDash on an e-bike, tony and the guests noted his striking resemblance in style, delivery, and appearance to the late Mitch Hedberg.

   Guests: Duncan Trussell, Ian Fidance.

   Watch set at 1:21:19View episode #730

Career Arc

Keegan Carmichael first came through Kill Tony's bucket lineup on #730 (Aug 4, 2025) with guests Duncan Trussell and Ian Fidance. He returned across 3 sets, most recently on #767 (May 11, 2026).

First pulled from the bucket in episode number 730.