Tony Scar
First pulled from the bucket in #752. First golden ticket set in #758.
- Appearances
- 4
- First episode
- #752
- Most recent
- #780
- Current status
- Golden Ticket
Career arc
Oldest to newestThis arc reflects the episodes indexed so far, not the full history of the show.
Appearances
- #7801:01:23Golden TicketMay 7, 2026
Golden ticket winner, one of the youngest ever and billed as the show's first musical prodigy; first ever appearance in LA. Performed an original guitar song about the American dream, including a running bit about hiring a local black guy to sing a line in every city. Tony ran the show's long-standing first-kiss segment for him - a woman from the audience came up and made out with him, which Tony called maybe the greatest kiss in Kill Tony history and replayed. Plugged his Too Soon podcast and his Golden Ticket tour.
- #7785:34Golden TicketJul 13, 2026
Opened the show as one of the youngest golden ticket winners ever (won at 21, now 22), doing an experimental musical set with his own lighting rig rigged as a fake lie detector. Talked about living in a studio apartment with a 20-year-old girlfriend he met on Hinge who has no car, no place and no GED, and about being broke while doing nothing but comedy. Plugged a tour at his own comedy site; name spelling confirmed by his own URL mention.
- #7581:42:06Golden TicketFeb 16, 2026
Closed the show at age 21 with a long musical-comedy number. Tony introduced him as the future of the show and of musical comedy, noting he had only been on once before and won a golden ticket that time. Said he now has managers and agents but still struggles to get booked around town.
- #75249:07Bucket PullDec 27, 2025
Bucket pull making his Kill Tony debut and the night's golden ticket winner (number four). 21 years old, nine months into comedy, started in Cedar Rapids, Iowa and moved to Austin about four months ago. Does musical comedy on guitar; his homeless love song earned a standing ovation and Tony called it one of the best sets he has seen from a young comic.