Mike St. Hilaire

First bucket pull of the night and his first time on the show. Twelve years in comedy, based in New York, grew up in Maine, and works as a reality-TV producer on a police ride-along show. Tony's critique was that he crammed roughly ninety seconds of material into his minute; the interview covered his real French surname, having no kids, gambling, a trip to Nairobi, moving to Maine for a girlfriend and taking a comedy break, and time spent filming inside 28 different jails.