
Lineup
- 1Gilbert Gottfried2:28Guest
Legendary New York comedian and roaster, host of Gilbert Gottfried's Amazing Colossal Podcast. This was his first time appearing on Kill Tony.
- 2Jane Riccobono8:36Bucket Pull
A midwife from New York City who has delivered 49 babies. This was her first time ever doing stand-up comedy, she signed up on a whim the day of the show.
- 3Sally Torta Gionni16:13Bucket Pull
From Poughkeepsie, New York, and has been doing comedy for four months. She performed the previous night in Poughkeepsie and decided to travel to NYC for this show. She is known for her ability to walk on her hands.
- 4Joe Vernie23:58Bucket Pull
Age 20, from New Jersey who works a desk job involving telephone poles. This was his first time doing stand-up, though he had been planning to try for two years. He performed with a purple cast on his arm from a skateboarding accident.
- 5Michaela Lizewski33:46Bucket Pull
From Staten Island, New York, and has been doing comedy for three months. She works as a shop manager at a tattoo parlor and is paid in tattoos. She mentioned having previously been in a coma due to meningitis.
- 6Ryan Anderson45:18Bucket Pull
Age 27, insurance worker from New York City. This was his first time doing stand-up comedy, he gave a very honest interview about a past group sexual encounter.
- 7Justin Wood Circus58:40Bucket Pull
He demonstrated high-level juggling and slinky tricks, a professional juggler from New York who attended circus school. He was invited to perform again after a successful set the previous night in Poughkeepsie.
- 8Blair Joseph1:07:12Bucket Pull
A barista from Upstate New York who claimed to have Lyme disease. This was his first time doing stand-up comedy. His set and interview were poorly received by the host and audience.
- 9David Jimenez1:15:19Bucket Pull
A real estate agent and second-generation Colombian. He had studied acting in college and performed in regional theater but had not been on a stage in 10 years, he struggled with nerves and memorizing his minute.
- 10Ronnie Rosenberg1:28:13Bucket Pull
Age 23, server at Red Lobster who is a big fan of the show. He returned to comedy after a year-long break due to being antisocial, he ended the show by performing a Stone Cold Stunner on Jeremiah Watkins.